Organizational types… my take: Organization as brain > Organization as organism > Organization as machine
Now, I wonder if you apply this framework to cities?
Pointer from: Michael Webb on Julia Galef podcast
Time digested: Oct 23, 2018
The Eight Metaphors of Organization
July 13, 2010 By Venkatesh Rao
Gareth Morgan’s Images of Organization is a must-read
Morgan’s book is based on the premise that almost all our thinking about organizations is based on one or more of eight basic metaphors. The main reason this book is hugely valuable is that 99% of organizational conversations stay exclusively within one metaphor. Worse, most people are permanently stuck in their favorite metaphor and simply cannot understand things said within other metaphors. So these are not really 8 perspectives, but 8 languages.
- Organization as Machine:
- Most simplistic
- Any geometrically structuralist approach also falls into this category
- little patience for people who use words/phrases like top down, bottom-up, centralized, decentralized and so forth, without realizing how narrow their view of organizations is
- mainstream Michael-Porter view of business is within this metaphor.
- Organization as Organism:
- suggests such ideas as "organizational DNA," birth, maturity and death, and so forth
- Organization as Brain:
- emphasis from "life processes" to learning.
- Organization as brain is the source of information-theoretic ways of understanding collectives ("who knows what," how information spreads and informs systems and processes).
- The System Dynamics people like this a lot, especially Peter Senge (The Fifth Discipline). I cannot recommend the SysDyn approach though; I think it is fundamentally flawed. But the learning view itself is very valuable.
- Organization as Culture:
- More so than others, culturalists tend to be extremists; they think the culture metaphor is the most important one, and this rigidity traps them in peculiar ways.
- Organization as Political System:
- Organization as Psychic Prison:
- symbol that Morgan uses is the Plato’s cave symbol
- Organization as System of Change and Flux:
- Think of a dynamically stable whirlpool or eddy in a flowing stream, and you get this one. It highlights some of the same aspects of organizations as the Organism metaphor, but in different ways.
- If the Machine metaphor is the dominant one, this one is the market-leading alternative metaphor.
- Organization as Instrument of Domination:
- This is NOT the same as the political metaphor, since it involves naked aggression in some form. This is where you get themes of oppression, sweat-shops, social costs (such as the BP oil spill), the military-industrial complex and so forth.